Spoiler Review
Betty Gardiner
Austen’s novel is imbued with subtle feminist hints. Each female character is brimming with kindness, intelligence and talent, yet they are almost claustrophobically confined to the sphere of the home, only hoping to achieve great marital matches. In her own ways, Austen satirizes this, and the film does too. It is cheeky and (gently) taunts the ridiculousness of 19th century social graces with a modern take. One obvious example being Emma’s nosebleed during the romantic climax of the film.
Emma is allowed to be a complex character. One that has zest and her own special power whilst also having arrogant and unlikeable moments. She is human, not the ‘angel of the house’ appearance expected from upper-class women at this time. This is true for the novel and film. She’s not all bad though and has many charming moments that transform her towards the end. Her change is what makes her story so compelling and also highlights a key message about the ignorance wealth can bring.
Outside of the symbolism in Emma’s plot, the costume and set design was particularly spectacular. It wouldn't be right if it was any other way. You can't make a period drama and not have beautiful Regency-era clothing and manor houses. Much of the costuming seemed historically accurate with its high waistline dresses, beautifully textured clothing and ridiculous hats, but I am no expert.
I found that the clothes really helped with the story too by giving insight to the characters. For example, Emma's outfits were extravagant compared to the less wealthy Harriet. However, as they spend more time together, Harriet's clothes imitate the stylish Emma's, although being more simple to reflect her social standing. This shows Emma’s influence over Harriet and their ever growing bond.
The film does a good job conveying Emma and Mr Knightly’s flirtatious rivalry. He teases Emma for being jealous of Jane and she praises Frank to get back at him. I am also glad they kept in my favourite line from the book. As Mr Knightly confesses his love for Emma he says ‘If I loved you less, I might be able to talk about it more.’ I find that quote so romantic and it was shot so well with the gorgeous countryside in the background. Peak period drama perfection!
As close as de Wilde gets to the novel, I appreciate the changes made to Mr Knightly’s character as I often found him stuffy in the book. He is far too much of a mentor to Emma which added an odd tinge to their romance, only heightened by his 16 year age gap. The movie’s Mr Knightly showed moments of vulnerability that put him on the same level as Emma. He could be just as shallow at times, not the know-all wisdom portrayed in the books. This made his love declaration much more powerful and their relationship what it needed to be — equal.
Overall, this is the kind of period drama I want to see. Let’s make them weird, more feminist and fun.